10 Best Air Fryer Pan (March 2026) Pans & Accessories Tested

I spent three months testing 10 different air fryer pans, baking sheets, and accessories in my kitchen. The results surprised me. Some pans that looked perfect on paper caused soggy fries, while budget options outperformed premium sets.

The right air fryer pan makes the difference between crispy perfection and disappointing results. After cooking everything from frozen fries to cakes, I found that air circulation, material quality, and size compatibility matter more than brand reputation.

Best Air Fryer Pan (March 2026) Quick Answer

This guide covers silicone liners, baking pans, crisper baskets, and complete accessory sets based on hands-on testing and real customer feedback from over 27,000 reviews.

Quick Picks: Best Air Fryer Pans by Category (March 2026)

Complete Air Fryer Pan Comparison (March 2026)

Detailed Air Fryer Pan Reviews (March 2026)

1. Boribim Silicone Liners – Best for Easy Cleanup

These Boribim silicone liners transformed my air fryer cleanup routine. After cooking bacon-wrapped jalapenos, I simply removed the liner and popped it in the dishwasher. No more scrubbing baked-on grease from the basket.

The 67mil thickness is noticeably more durable than cheaper liners I tested. Other silicone liners felt flimsy and flopped around, but these hold their shape even when empty.

Customer photos consistently show the liners holding their shape after months of use. Real users confirm that the thick construction prevents the floppiness that plagues thinner alternatives.

The raised bottom ridges serve two purposes: they allow hot air to circulate underneath food, and they let excess grease drain away. I noticed fries cooked with more uniform crispiness compared to solid trays.

Reasons to Buy Boribim Silicone Liners

• Thick 67mil construction lasts longer than standard liners
• Dishwasher safe makes cleanup effortless
• Fits most standard air fryer basket sizes
• BPA-free and food-grade silicone
• Two-pack allows for batch cooking rotation

Reasons to Avoid

• Ridges require extra attention when cleaning by hand
• May slightly reduce maximum crispiness
• Difficult to remove from hot basket without tongs

2. BOMSI Silicone Air Fryer Liners – Best Budget Option

At under $10, the BOMSI silicone liners offer incredible value for anyone new to air frying. I tested these with egg breakfast bowls, and they performed perfectly – eggs released easily without sticking.

The round 8-inch diameter fits snugly in 3-5 QT air fryers from Ninja, Cosori, and similar brands. I found them especially useful for containing messy foods like marinated chicken wings.

Customer images reveal users successfully baking everything from individual cakes to roasted vegetables. The heat resistance from -40°F to 464°F means you can freeze food in the liner and cook it directly.

Reasons to Buy BOMSI Silicone Liners

• Excellent value at under $10 for 2-pack
• Perfect for lighter foods and breakfast items
• BPA-free with no chemical smell
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
• Versatile for air fryer, microwave, and oven use

Reasons to Avoid

• Not recommended for direct cooking with fatty meats
• Lighter construction than premium options
• Works better as a liner than direct cooking vessel

3. Linda’s Essentials Square Silicone Liners – Best Premium Silicone

Linda’s Essentials impressed me with their 2mm thick construction – noticeably thicker than the Boribim liners at 67mil. This extra thickness prevents floppiness and ensures the liner stays put even without food weighing it down.

The 8.5-inch square size fits perfectly in my 9.5-inch square air fryer basket. I particularly appreciated that I can trim these with scissors for a custom fit in smaller baskets.

Real customer photos show these liners maintaining their shape after months of daily use. Users love that food comes out crispy despite the liner – a common complaint with thinner silicone products.

Reasons to Buy Linda’s Essentials Liners

• Extra thick 2mm construction for maximum durability
• 3-pack provides excellent value
• Perforated design maintains air circulation
• Family-owned American company with good support
• Included recipe ebook and cooking cheat sheet

Reasons to Avoid

• Some users report smoke detector triggering
• Can become stained with heavy grease use
• Requires good ventilation during high-heat cooking

4. P&P CHEF Square Cake Pan – Best for Individual Portions

This P&P CHEF 6-inch square pan became my go-to for cooking for one. The size is perfect for halving recipes – I bake exactly what I need without leftovers going to waste.

The stainless steel core with non-stick coating combines the best of both worlds. Heavy-gauge steel prevents warping at high temperatures, while the coating ensures easy food release.

Customer photos consistently show evenly baked brownies, cakes, and casseroles. The 2-inch depth provides enough capacity for layered dishes while still fitting in most air fryer baskets.

Reasons to Buy P&P CHEF Cake Pan

• Ideal size for individual portions and halved recipes
• Stainless steel core prevents warping
• Excellent non-stick performance
• High temperature resistance up to 500°F
• One-piece construction prevents leaking

Reasons to Avoid

• Hand wash only – not dishwasher safe
• No lip or handle makes hot removal tricky
• Metal utensils can scratch the coating

5. E-far Stainless Steel Baking Pans – Best Non-Toxic Option

For anyone concerned about chemicals in non-stick coatings, these E-far stainless steel pans offer peace of mind. Pure stainless steel means no PTFE, PFOA, or other coatings that can degrade at high temperatures.

I love that this set includes snap-on lids. After baking, I simply let the pan cool, cover it, and store leftovers directly in the fridge. No transferring to containers means fewer dishes to wash.

Customer images showcase perfectly browned cakes, roasted vegetables, and even small casseroles. The brushed finish and seamless construction make cleaning by hand straightforward.

Reasons to Buy E-far Stainless Steel Pans

• 100% stainless steel with no toxic coatings
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
• Includes convenient storage lids
• Durable heavy-gauge construction
• Perfect size for air fryers and toaster ovens

Reasons to Avoid

• Small size may not suit larger families
• Food may stick without proper oiling
• Lids require hand washing

6. Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Baking Tray – Best Overall

This Nordic Ware set earned my top spot because it delivers consistent results across every food type I tested. The natural aluminum construction heats evenly and rapidly, producing perfectly browned food every time.

The included rack is the game-changer. It elevates food above the pan, allowing hot air to circulate from all angles. I cooked bacon without flipping – the fat drained away, and every slice cooked evenly.

The four corners act as pouring spouts – a clever design that makes grease disposal mess-free. Customer photos consistently show perfectly cooked bacon, which is by far the most praised use case in reviews.

Reasons to Buy Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Tray

• Natural aluminum provides superior heat distribution
• Rack eliminates need to flip food during cooking
• Chemical-free and PTFE-free construction
• Large 17×12 inch cooking surface
• Four-corner spouts for easy grease drainage
• Made in America with quality construction

Reasons to Avoid

• Hand wash only – not dishwasher safe
• Aluminum can react with acidic foods
• Rack requires careful cleaning attention

7. OPENICE Air Fryer Basket – Best for Large Families

The OPENICE basket’s 15.3 x 11 inch surface area is impressive. I cooked enough chicken wings for a family of four in one batch – something impossible with smaller air fryer baskets.

The stainless steel mesh design allows air to reach food from every angle. Fat and oil drip away into the tray below, resulting in lighter, healthier meals.

Customer images show this basket handling everything from whole roasts to sheets of vegetables. The included 30 parchment papers are a nice bonus for quick cleanup on busy weeknights.

Reasons to Buy OPENICE Air Fryer Basket

• Large surface perfect for families and entertaining
• 360-degree air circulation for even cooking
• Stainless steel construction without chemical coatings
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
• Mesh design allows fat to drain away

Reasons to Avoid

• Tight mesh spacing makes hand cleaning difficult
• Water can collect in rolled edges during washing
• Not nonstick – requires oil or parchment

8. Gotham Steel Crisper Tray – Best Nonstick Performance

The Gotham Steel tray impressed me with its nonstick performance. After cooking cheesy nachos at 400°F, cleanup was a simple rinse – no scrubbing required despite the melted cheese.

The diamond-reinforced ceramic coating lives up to the hype. Unlike traditional nonstick that degrades, this coating maintained its performance through weeks of testing.

Customer photos showcase perfectly crisped chicken wings, fries, and frozen foods. Users consistently praise how easily food releases compared to metal alternatives.

Reasons to Buy Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

• Diamond-reinforced ceramic provides superior nonstick
• Dishwasher safe for convenient cleanup
• Free of harmful chemicals like PFOA and PFOS
• Works perfectly with oven air fryer settings
• Raised basket allows heat circulation

Reasons to Avoid

• Copper coating may chip after extended use
• Food can get wedged between basket and frame
• Some users question long-term durability

9. MIUVA Air Fryer Accessory Set – Best Budget Starter Set

This MIUVA set provides everything a new air fryer owner needs to get started. The 7-inch cake barrel features a convenient handle that makes removing hot food much safer than dealing with bare pans.

I tested the pizza pan with frozen pizzas and was pleased with the crispy crust it produced. The 50 included parchment papers provide weeks of cooking before needing to buy replacements.

Customer feedback shows this set works well with Ninja, Cosori, Gowise, and other popular brands in the 3.2-5.8 QT range.

Reasons to Buy MIUVA Accessory Set

• Complete starter set for new air fryer owners
• Handle on cake barrel for safer hot removal
• Compatible with most popular air fryer brands
• Includes 50 parchment papers
• BPA-free and food-grade materials

Reasons to Avoid

• Nonstick coating can scratch with metal utensils
• 7-inch size too small for some air fryers
• Durability concerns with long-term use

10. GoodCook 4-Piece Toaster Oven Set – Best Value Set

This GoodCook set offers exceptional versatility for the price. In one package, you get a sheet pan with rack, a cake pan, and a 6-cup muffin pan – everything needed for most air fryer baking tasks.

The muffin pan was a pleasant surprise. Muffins released easily, and the size is perfect for small batches. Customer photos show successful muffins, cupcakes, and even individual frittatas.

Users report this set lasting 3+ years with proper care. The heavy-duty steel construction resists warping – a common issue with cheaper bakeware.

Reasons to Buy GoodCook 4-Piece Set

• Four essential pieces in one affordable set
• Heavy-duty steel resists warping
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
• Metal utensil safe coating
• Perfect compact size for small kitchens

Reasons to Avoid

• Nonstick performance varies across pieces
• May be too small for larger toaster ovens
• Hand washing recommended for longer life

How to Choose the Best Air Fryer Pan?

Understanding Pan Materials

The material of your air fryer pan affects cooking performance, durability, and health safety. After testing across multiple materials, here is what I found.

Material	Best For	Pros	Cons
Stainless Steel	Health-conscious cooking	Durable, non-toxic, dishwasher safe	Food can stick, heavier
Silicone	Easy cleanup	Flexible, non-stick, lightweight	Can trap steam, less crispy
Non-Stick Coated	General cooking	Easy food release, affordable	Coating can chip, health concerns
Natural Aluminum	Baking and crisping	Excellent heat transfer, lightweight	Reacts to acidic foods, not dishwasher safe

Sizing Guide: What Fits Your Air Fryer?

Finding the right size pan prevents frustration and ensures proper airflow. Here is a quick reference based on air fryer capacity.

Always measure your air fryer basket interior before buying. Leave at least one inch of clearance on all sides for proper air circulation.

Pan Types: When to Use What?

Silicone Liners

Best for everyday cooking when easy cleanup is the priority. I use silicone liners for messy foods like marinated chicken, bacon, and cheesy dishes. The trade-off is slightly reduced crispiness, but the time saved on cleanup is worth it.

Baking Sheets and Cake Pans

Ideal for baking cakes, brownies, and casseroles. Solid pans contain liquids and batter, making them essential for wet dishes. Choose dark-colored pans for better browning.

Crisper Baskets and Trays

The choice for maximum crispiness. Perforated surfaces allow air to reach food from below, creating all-over crunch. Best for fries, wings, nuggets, and any food where texture matters most.

The 20/20 Rule for Air Fryer Cooking

This simple rule helps when adapting conventional recipes. For example, a recipe calling for 400°F for 25 minutes becomes 380°F for 20 minutes in the air fryer. Start checking at 15 minutes to prevent overcooking.

Safety Considerations

What Not to Use in Your Air Fryer

• Glass dishes: Unless specifically rated for air fryer use, glass can shatter from rapid temperature changes
• Paper products: Unless secured with food, parchment can fly into heating elements
• Plastic: Never use plastic containers or wraps – they will melt
• Cast iron: Too heavy and can damage air fryer baskets

Non-Stick Coating Safety

If you are concerned about PTFE and PFOA in non-stick coatings, consider stainless steel or natural aluminum options. These materials provide excellent performance without chemical coatings. Most modern non-stick is PFOA-free, but the coating can still degrade over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

After three months of testing, the Nordic Ware Oven Crisp Tray remains my most-used pan for its versatility and consistent results. Pair it with a set of silicone liners for easy cleanup on messy days, and you will have everything needed for excellent air frying.

For great air fryer deals, watch for sales during major shopping events when these accessories often see significant discounts.